Guests love . Crickets. Meanwhile, we can only hope that the police investigation has the balls to investigate ALL leads (govmint and Hillsongish). Weeks later. Thats a significant amount of deaths for one incident. Homicide is regarded as the most serious criminal offence in both jurisdictions. The International Transport Workers' Federation had called on the Australian government to allow the crew members to be disembarked so that they could be flown to their countries of residence. [32] About 900 passengers from countries other than Australia left Sydney after the ships arrival there; few specifics are known about infections or deaths in this group. [34] According to an inquiry by Bret Walker SC for the New South Wales government, the eventual death toll was at least 28, including eight from the United States. Yet all the ship's passengers were disembarked six hours later. 13 August 2020. Jerry Lee Lewis and other famous men who GET AWAY with rape and murder, SCOTLANDS FOOTBALL ABUSE SCANDAL ON BRINK OF EXPLODING! In early 1992, with Premier Greiner having to govern in a minority government with the support of independents, Hazzard thought he had a bright idea when he remembered that former Liberal MP turned Independent, Terry Metherell, had previously expressed interest in gaining a cushy, plum directors job with the Environmental Protection Authority. Ahead of this years BAD Sydney Festival, Therese Taylor speaks with one of its special guests novelist Michael Mohammed Ahmad about the realities of crime and ethnicity. Is this the reason the Ruby Princess docked quickly? Health Department senior staff were working under difficult conditions, he said, and added: I find it disappointing, in the strongest way possible, that there can be any suggestion that those people are not doing their best.. And while not an overly active ship, people were always engaged -- whether it was . [9] A cluster of cases in New Zealand was also linked to the ship. The Ruby Princess cruise liner that was allowed to dock in Sydney over a fortnight ago during a worldwide pandemic with its 2,700 passengers not undergoing health checks is now the leading cause of COVID-19 infection in Australia, accounting for about one tenth of total cases. Allowing a boat with Hillsong members to dock wouldnt be the first time that Morrison has granted favour to his church during the COVID pandemic. Novak Djokovic gets to work . Nour Ahmad reports. The stakes are high because 12 passengers have died and 2,700 passengers were allowed to leave the toxic liner to board planes, buses and taxis to return home and travel interstate and overseas, thereby spreading infection. But Barnaby Joyce never answered our questions. Alex Mitchell is a former State Political Editor of Sydneys Sun-Herald and a regular Friday contributor to John Menadues Pearls & Irritations. Heres Inqs list of 10 questions the commissioner should ask. A night out with Behrouz Boochani and friends in Australia, WHATS WRONG WITH RYDE? Enjoy fast, reliable Wi-Fi, TrulyTouchless experiences, food and drinks delivered wherever you are and so much more. #auspol: Nov-28,2022 20:03 Whilst the government refuses to identify the ministers responsible for docking, in thinly veiled hopes the incident will somehow blow over, sources have grown frustrated with the negligence and reached out to journalists. The luxurious Ruby Princess left Sydney on March 8 with 2,700 passengers who had paid top dollar for a 10-day cruise described in brochures as the holiday of a lifetime. Hawke has been a member since at least 2005 whilst Morrison has been outspoken about his Pentecostal beliefs throughout his Prime Ministership. You cant be serious, Mr Jones said by email. I want not just to resist those things that are harmful but to support those things that are good. There was a swing against the Liberals of 7.9 points, but Hawke won the seat with 61.6 per cent of the vote on a two-party-preferred basis. [8] By August, the total number of deaths associated with the ship was 28 and the number of infections was estimated at no fewer than 900. He is an investigative journalist and editor with a colourful career spanning across print, online, radio and television. alex hawke ruby princess. Former NSW Premier Nick Greiner and his corruption case in 1992 links NSW Health Minister Brad Hazzard to senior personnel at Carnival Cruises (Image: ABC). Contact us on: support@crikey.com.au or call the hotline: +61 (03) 8623 9900. EXCLUSIVE: Former 2SM radio host, Marcus Paul, has revealed he was left angry and disappointed by his sacking and believes he was held to a different standard by commercial radio bosses due to his modern takes. From my understanding, the Commonwealth Government had superior or at least equivalent jurisdiction under The Federal Biosecurity Act over all the issues surrounding the Ruby Princess and any other foreign vessel entering Australian ports. How often? [44] A defamation claim was made by Limontono, directed at Buzzfeed, which was settled out of court in 2019. [27] [28], Through his position in the ministry he has called for closer ties to the Pacific region, and to assist them with development. That thread appears to start with a cartoonist for a daily paper (not in SA). My only interest is the greater good for the Australian population. Prior to these, he served as Assistant Minister for Home Affairs in the Second Turnbull Ministry from December 2017 to August 2018. Choose from a variety of Alaska cruise and cruisetour itineraries and connect . If I had my opportunity to have my two bobs worth, with the benefit of what we now know about those people Id have said yeah, maybe we should hold them on the ship, he said on March 21. Alex Hawke was active in the preselection battle involving Sussan Ley and Trent Zimmerman. Hawke was seen as the tactical leader of the effort to unseat Turnbull. Zion Graphics was owned by Rudy Limantono, then president of the Bella Vista Liberal party branch and party donor. The NSW Governments grief began on March 19 when permission was given for passengers from the Ruby Princess to disembark, although it was then known some of them were suffering viral symptoms. Explore The Shops of Princess, celebrate cultures at our Festivals of the World or learn a new talent our onboard activities will keep you engaged every moment of your cruise vacation.1, Original musicals, dazzling magic shows, feature films, top comedians and nightclubs that get your feet movin and groovin. [4], Hawke attended Hills Grammar School and Cumberland High School. Just like Mcfailre Cash, Angus Garrad Taylor, Beetrooter Barnaby and Bridget McKenzie were mysteriously exempt from further investigation. That was not good enough for some, so Maiden revealed that she had done the logical thing and asked Hawke. Personalized. Meanwhile, Morrisons strange disappearance and tired and withdrawn reappearance comes as pharmaceutical giant Pfizer admits that more than two booster shots are needed for people to be adequately protected from the dangerous Delta strain of the virus. Some of them are now dead, others are on life support in a critical condition, and more than 620 have been tested positive for COVID-19 which accounts for 10% of Australias confirmed cases, while some from Port Kembla are locked up in hotel rooms in stifling quarantine going stir crazy. From the moment you step aboard, we want you to feel welcomed and right at home. Allegedly the in-laws of Hawke were on . RLA BATTLERS IN THE BUSH MAIDEN PACE (4YO and older) A couple of hours later 2700 passengers disembarked and went out into the population and overseas to spread the disease. [23] There were also claims that Hawke had inside information[clarification needed] coming from Bert van Manen, one of the deputy whips, who was also part of Morrison's bible study group.[24]. Regardless of what state and federal government people say, Carnival Cruises should NOT receive any help from ANY government around the world. Allegedly the in-laws of Hawke were on board the ship, along with other passengers from the Hillsong church that his family are a part of. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. COVID-19 vaccine access for our region. Princess Cruises' Ruby Princess ship docked Thursday in San Francisco with a dozen COVID-19 cases among passengers. World No. The Ruby Princess is a Crown-class cruise ship owned and operated by Princess Cruises.. The Ruby Princess cruise liner that was allowed to dock in Sydney over a fortnight ago during a worldwide pandemic with its 2,700 passengers not undergoing health checks is now the leading cause of COVID-19 infection in Australia, accounting for about one tenth of total cases. Buzzfeed issued an apology, which included a statement clarifying that it had not intended to present Zion Graphics as anything other than a legitimate business. My Cart 0 The Ruby Princess heading out of Sydney Harbour on 19 March Health authorities in Australia have been heavily criticised in an official inquiry into the Ruby Princess cruise ship. Scott Morrison's plan to become PM", "Dutton's Keystone Cops and Morrison's prayer: five key moments from Niki Savva's book", "Who's who in the Liberals' left, right and centre factions? Serkan Ozturk is the publisher of True Crime News Weekly. Authors Channel Summit. Men principal. It is now seeking $6 billion in funding as it seeks to survive the potential death sentence the Coronavirus has given cruise ships the world over. [26], Another three passengers from the ship were reported dead in New South Wales on 5 April,[27] and a fourth in Queensland. Describing the Ruby Princess is one of the greatest public health failures in NSW history Ms McKay accused the Government of cover-up and added: As a result, we are today calling for the Health Minister to stand aside. Has the police commissioners huge sudden recent payrise had any bearing on this matter, I had thought it unthinkable previously ,but this government has proved such a rats nest that the unthinkable is an almost daily occurrence. Every hour, our chefs are busy baking, grilling and sauting great-tasting fare from scratch. Alan Cadman, who had been the member for Mitchell since 1974, chose not to contest the preselection,[11] but was later quoted as saying that this was due to "relentless branch-stacking within the electorate. Immigration Minister Alex Hawke can send Djokovic packing. Show of. [52], In April 2022, the Ruby Princess and 52 other cruise ships were under investigation by the CDC for excessive COVID-19 outbreaks on board their vessels since the start of the year. Most recently Scott Morrison took part in a 25-hour prayer marathon held over Zoom last weekend. When challenged on these statements, Hawke responded by saying that Labor were "feigning outrage and falsely claiming racism" in order to shut down debate, and that they were "fixated on identity politics and appears constantly triggered by anything and everything". [2][6], Hawke joined the Liberal Party in 1995, and was elected vice-president of the NSW Division of the Young Liberal Movement in 2001, and became president in 2002. 0:00. The response to this post has been overwhelming with over 68,000 views, along with trending on Australian Reddit and Twitter, all within less than 24 hours. There is certainly a vast appetite for this sort of rumour. When Premier Berejiklian threw NSW Police Commissioner Mick Fuller a hospital pass and told him to launch a homicide inquiry into the States biggest (health) disaster, the veteran policeman said laconically: There are 10 deaths relating from the Ruby. More than 1000 cases of COVID-19 are estimated to have come from the Ruby Princess passengers who disembarked in Sydney on March 19, four days after Mr Morrison said ships would only put passengers ashore "directly under the command" of the Australian Border Force. I am autistic woman confined to my house indefinitely with a pre-existing lung condition. It also carries mandatory jail sentences in both countries. The NSW Government announced today that NSW Police Commissioner Mick Fuller has been tasked with investigating the circumstances surrounding the docking of the Ruby Princess. Alexander Hawke is a British Lord and a secret agent. [18], In his maiden speech in the House of Representatives, Hawke described his political beliefs as follows: "My brand of Liberalism is more interested in what we support than what we oppose. Coronavirus 6:19pm Aug 14, 2020 pic.twitter.com/aqVuKUQ07K, Michael Atkinson (@MickAtko) April 26, 2020, Hillsong has a huge kids convention called Kidsong, booked for Sydney in May Morrison needs to get restrictions on kids lifted so it can go ahead. It seem they were unwilling to act. While Berejiklian has claimed it was Border Force which erroneously classified the Ruby Princess as low risk of COVID-19 transmission and thats why NSW Health officials were not there to greet the ships passengers upon its arrival in Sydney. On 15 April, the NSW State Government announced a Special Commission of inquiry to investigate events surrounding the Ruby Princess. They are among the best at sea or anywhere. article on the inner city news site Cityhub the next day. [10] Brogden's claims were strongly denied by Hawke, who stated "I have not spoken to a single journalist, on or off the record, about this matter until now and I was not in attendance at the function where Brogden committed these acts. Ruby Princess: the untrue Hillsong slur that Twitter can't let go of. Feb. 7, 2023 Ted Bell, a former award-winning advertising copywriter and creative director who abandoned Madison Avenue in his early 50s to recast himself as a best-selling novelist by writing and. There is a good need to discover why. Onboard activities spark curiosity and fuel creativity while excursions ashore engage and inspire! "[43], On 7 April 2020, it was reported that the New Zealand Prime Minister, Jacinda Ardern, had requested Crown Law to check whether her country's laws had been broken. "[6] Hawke strongly rejected various reports and allegations that he is a "right-wing extremist", saying he represents the values of his electorate. [15], Ruby Princess' visit to Napier on 15 March 2020 led to a cluster of 16 COVID-19 cases there. My hope for writing this was to push the friends I have, who are real journalists, into investigating more and exposing the complete truth. [8][9] The next day on 30 August 2005, Brogden was admitted to hospital after committing an apparent attempt at suicide in his electoral office. . Morrison brought cameras inside his familys church for their Easter service last year. [34][35] He has also claimed that no one has done more to negate the effects of regional climate change than Australia, a claim the Pacific nations reject. The Ruby Princess arrived in San Francisco on April 11 after a trip to Hawaii in which 143 passengers on board tested positive for the virus, the city's health department told CBS MoneyWatch.. Uni library staff angry after bosses worked from home last week while they were forced onto frontline against COVID-19, there are 600 cases of COVID-19 in Australia, has claimed it was NSW Healths role to check the ships passengers. No reason was explicitly given for the delay between the announcement and the commencement of the ban, but Hillsongs Colour Conference in Sydneys North East was attended by over 3000 people on Saturday, March14th. Describing the Ruby Princess is "one of the greatest public health failures in NSW history" Ms McKay accused the Government of cover-up and added: "As a result, we are today calling for the Health Minister to stand aside. For his part, Hazzard did not respond to our requests for comment sent by text message to his media team. Alex Mitchell is a former Sydney Sun-Herald State Political Editor whose commentary appears every week. If the chatter across social media is to be believed, it is being said that Liberal MP and Assistant Defence Minister, Alex Hawke, who represents the Hills District in Sydney's bible belt, called ScuM for assistance to get the boat disembarked. The cases emerged in additional testing requested by the . [28] A report by The Guardian's Matilda Boseley commented: "Since the ship's 2,700 passengers were allowed to freely disembark in Sydney on 19 March, federal and state authorities have been pinballing blame. All people on the Hawaii cruise were vaccinated. Footage was initially uploaded by Eternity News before being deleted. In 2001, he commenced work as an adviser to the Senator Helen Coonan, then Minister for Revenue and Assistant Treasurer, advising on taxation, superannuation and insurance matters during the time of the HIH liquidation. Sleepy Sydney suburb set to be key seat in NSW election, NSW POLICE TERRORISE JOURNALIST AFTER HE EXPOSES CORRUPT COPS! The commissioner said preliminary inquiries into phone call logs, email correspondence, radio transmissions and other documents had raised concerns about potentially misleading conduct. As the crisis has continued to escalate the government has been forced to take stricter measures in regards to lockdowns. Uni library staff angry after bosses worked from home last week while they were forced onto frontline against COVID-19. NSW Chief Medical Officer Ms Kerry Chant said the passenger arrivals were low risk because they were suffering nothing more serious than influenza activity. Edit April 3rd 6:26 PM : Since the publishing of the post, journalist Samantha Maiden has refuted these claims as rumours. Does anyone believe them? A further embellishment sometimes found in tweets suggests they were connected to the Hillsong Colour Conference because, allegedly, they attended it. The company responsible for the printing, Zion Graphics, owned no commercial printer but instead outsourced the printing and charged a premium for the service. Hawke in the following years used his balance of power position on state executive to coerce the moderates into parachuting factional allies as Liberal Candidates despite the wishes of local branch members. Alexander George Hawke (born 9 July 1977) is an Australian politician who served as Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs from 2020 to 2022 in the Morrison Government. [37], On 14 January 2022, Hawke exercised personal ministerial powers under sections 133C(3) and 116(1)(e)(i) of the Migration Act 1958 to cancel the visa of No.1 ranked ATP tennis player Novak Djokovic a few days prior to the commencement of the 2022 Australian Open Grand Slam. The NSW Police have been granted extra powers to enforce a mandatory lockdown where people can no longer leave the house for non-essential reasons. 21 August 2020. Princess offers unparalleled inclusive dining options throughout the ship with a wide range of culinary delights to suit any palate, from endless buffet choice to gourmet pizza, frosty treats, decadent desserts and much more. Revitalize and refresh body, mind and soul with Princess. The Ruby Princess was built in 2008 by Fincantieri in Trieste, Italy, as a sister ship to Crown Princess and Emerald Princess.She was turned over to Carnival Corporation and Princess Cruises in late October 2008. RT @HeathdonSMcGreg: Careful, isn't Robodebt on the ABC blacklist? Unsuccessful. Hawke has served as Member of Parliament (MP) for Mitchell since 2007, representing the Liberal Party . Almost 2,700 passengers - some coughing and spluttering - were allowed to leave. He was reported to have abstained from the final vote on the Marriage Amendment (Definition and Religious Freedoms) Act 2017, which legalised same-sex marriage. Scott Morrison doesnt deny bringing back Covid from UK after finally coming out of hiding looking tired & short of breath as Pfizer admits vaccine doesnt protect from Delta strain, IM NOT A RIGHT-WING SHOCK JOCK! [14], On 8 March 2020, Ruby Princess departed Sydney, Australia for a 13-night cruise around New Zealand. Assistant Immigration Minister Alex Hawke latest MP in citizenship fiasco. You'll find our specialty restaurants are the perfect place to celebrate any occasion.1, On every Princess ship, you'll find so many ways to play, day or night. In December 2020, Hawke was appointed Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs in the Morrison ministry and served until May 2022, following the appointment of the Albanese ministry. Swan Hill, VIC (Night) - Wednesday, 8 Mar 2023. Alex Hawke is a British aristocrat, former Royal Navy Commander, business tycoon, and sometime adventurer for the British and American governments. These restrictions are set to be lifted on July 1, which is conveniently one week before Hillsongs next scheduled mega conference to be held at Qudos Bank Arena over 4 days. For a number of years I was state political reporter for the Sydney Sun and the Seven Network so I would have interviewed him quite often as a working journalist, a Walkley award winning one at that. June 29, 2022; seattle seahawks schedule 2023; psalms in spanish for funeral . Seasonal and Pacific workers to help fill labour gaps. [38] 542 crew members were taken off the ship for repatriation to Brazil, Canada, France, Germany, Japan, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand, the Philippines, the United Kingdom and the United States between 21 and 23 April. One person was hospitalised. That list will quickly be classified as on-water matters and not for public viewing. This is his agency.. The medias post mortem into the Ruby Princess tragedy has been remarkable. In a supporting statement, NSW Health said: No cases of COVID-19 were identified on board the ship before it docked. This claim is disputed by emails, phone calls, NZ evidence, passenger statements and media reports. David Jones and the Ruby Princess in October last year (Image: Facebook / Supplied). "[13] After his preselection, The Sydney Morning Herald reported Hawke's comments that he believes that Australia will move increasingly towards an American model of conservatism and that "The two greatest forces for good in human history are capitalism and Christianity, and when they're blended it's a very powerful duo. The magnitude 5.1 earthquake which rocked Te Aroha and was felt extensively throughout Waip at 5.39am on January 4 was a major talking point on social media. [14], Passengers on the Hawaii trip stated that it was quite clear that a large number of passengers were ill but unless they self-reported, they were free to move around the ship. Crikey acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the many nations across Australia, and pay our respect to Elders past and present. Mr Jones did not comment when asked whether Carnival had acted appropriately and in the best interests of public health during its docking of the Ruby Princess in Sydney on March 19. [47][48] It published its report on 14 August 2020. ", "Ruby Princess: New South Wales premier apologises over cruise ship outbreak", "Princess Cruises Debuts New "Ultimate Ship Tour" with Launch of Ruby Princess", "Europe 2014 Page 3 Cruise Critic Message Board Forums", "Fremantle to keep cruise ships after port access stoush", "Ruby Princess cruise ship docked in San Francisco with 143 cases of COVID-19", "Anatomy of a coronavirus disaster: how 2,700 people were let off the Ruby Princess cruise ship by mistake", "Three New Cases Of COVID-19 In HB One Linked To Cruise Ship Ruby Princess", "Coronavirus: New Hawke's Bay cluster linked to Ruby Princess cruise ship responsible for hundreds of Australian cases", "Ruby Princess rushed back to Sydney with COVID-19 swabs", "Coronavirus: thousands who left cruise ship in Sydney told to self-isolate after three people test positive", "Coronavirus infections in NSW pass 800, Australia's eighth death confirmed", "More than 400 coronavirus cases 10% of Australia's total are from Ruby Princess cruise ship", "Coronavirus death in ACT was a passenger on the under-fire Ruby Princess cruise ship", "Coronavirus: calls to repatriate 15,000 crew members from cruise ships off Australia's coast", "Two cruise ships agree to leave Australian waters as police raise hopes of resolving standoff", "NSW coronavirus death toll rises, with three people dying after travelling on the Ruby Princess", "Ruby Princess coronavirus deaths to be subject of criminal investigation by NSW Police homicide squad", "WA coronavirus deaths rise to four as man from Ruby Princess dies of COVID-19 at Royal Perth Hospital", "Tasmanian man in his 80s becomes state's third coronavirus fatality", "Criminal investigation launched into Ruby Princess cruise ship coronavirus disaster", "Coronavirus outbreak on Ruby Princess claims second US man, family launches $1.6 million lawsuit", "Coronavirus concerns for 900 international passengers on Ruby Princess, who are not included in official stats", "Australia's coronavirus death toll rises after 81yo Ruby Princess passenger becomes latest fatality", "Ruby Princess coronavirus inquiry slams 'inexcusable' mistakes made by NSW Health", "NSW health minister defends experts who handled Ruby Princess coronavirus outbreak", "NSW Police seize Ruby Princess's 'black box' in overnight raid for coronavirus investigation", "First Ruby Princess crew members disembark after coronavirus isolation, hundreds still left on board", "Coronavirus-hit Ruby Princess departs Port Kembla for international waters", "Ruby Princess crew fear for their health as ship leaves Australia", "Cruise ship linked to Australia coronavirus infections sails into Manila", "Coronavirus: Jacinda Ardern seeks legal advice on Ruby Princess cruise ship", "Strike Force Bast underway to investigate actions surrounding Ruby Princess", "Special commission of inquiry into Ruby Princess", "Hearings - The Special Commission of Inquiry into the Ruby Princess", "Report finds federal government failings likely contributed to Ruby Princess COVID-19 disaster", "Confidence testing for at-border delivery of critical human biosecurity functions Ruby Princess cruise ship incident", "Inspector-General of Biosecurity review of at-border delivery of human biosecurity functions Ruby Princess cruise ship incident", Special Commission of Inquiry into the Ruby Princess, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ruby_Princess&oldid=1093275789, This page was last edited on 15 June 2022, at 15:29. To connect a sign in method the email must match the one on your Crikey account. See the complete profile on LinkedIn and discover Ruby Alexandra's connections and jobs at similar companies. NSW Health Minister Brad Hazzard (Image: NSW Parliament). Hawke was born on 9 July 1977 in Wollongong, New South Wales. [31] However these new closer ties did not require further action on climate change despite the calls from Pacific leaders for Australia to reduce their carbon emissions to help the low lying Pacific islands. He has had his journalism previously featured by Sydney Morning Herald, Crikey, Australian Doctor, Ruptly, Dopamine Magazine, City Hub and the Star Observer. Alex Hawke is tracking one of the world's most powerful villains high in the Swiss Alps A powerful Swiss banker is found dead, frozen at the base of a soaring Alp. They have the NSW Police investigators looking into who is culpable for this disaster. 0:49. Alexander George Hawke (born 9 July 1977) is an Australian politician who served as Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs from 2020 to 2022 in the Morrison Government. BAD Sydney to hear from voices that matter, BRISBANE BOWLO BASH! 1953 [11], Ruby Princess was initially based in Los Angeles for cruises to the Mexican Riviera, Hawaii and California coastal cruises. Being involved in the downfall of your own Liberal Party premier on corruption charges is something that would be hard to forget. Premier Greiner subsequently created the job for Metherell but would end up losing his own after being called to front the ICAC on corruption charges. The Crikey comment section is members-only content. Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs, Minister for International Development and the Pacific, 2018 Liberal Party of Australia leadership spills, Marriage Amendment (Definition and Religious Freedoms) Act 2017, "Ministerial Arrangements | Prime Minister of Australia", "Mr Alex Hawke MP, Member for Mitchell (NSW) First Speech To Parliament", "Knives out: a raucous party, a Nazi uniform and a Liberal Party mystery", "Young Lib taunts the wets: go to the Greens", "Age does not worry him, says Lib hopeful", "Hawke secures Liberal preselection for Mitchell", "PM defends Liberal Hawke's preselection", "Social Security and Veterans' Affairs Legislation amendment (Enhanced Allowances) Bill 2008", "Mitchell MP Alex Hawke given key economic role in Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull's new ministry", "The rise of the next generation of factional leaders", "Christian.